Low value content is destroying your website
By Gerry McGovernLow-value content is destroying the usefulness of intranets and public websites. It needs to be stored separately.
Andrew Leung is a computer science researcher at the University of California. His team analyzed a large data/content environment over a three month period. Their findings included the following:
- More than 90 percent of the files were never accessed.
- Of those files accessed, 65 percent were only opened once.
- Most of the rest were opened five or fewer times
- About a dozen files were opened 100,000 times or more.
Recently, I've been testing the quality of a search engine for a commercial organization's public website. This organization sells a wide range of products, and its customers' search behavior reflects this.
However, what I find when searching for some of this company's most popular products is that the search results are full of links to the press archive and other old, out-of date content. Some of the content is misleading and wrong, talking about, for example, a feature for a product that has long since been replaced.
Poor quality, low grade, minor-interest content is choking the usefulness of the search engine. I find this happens again and again and again. It happens on intranets, many of which have become dumping grounds for low quality content.
One reason intranets have become such dumping grounds is because a great many organizations have no clear strategy in relation to how they manage their content/data. Because there is no other place to put "stuff", many people simply store it on the intranet, which of course bulges and bulges and bulges.
Governments have a particularly severe problem when it comes to managing content. A key reason is because the Freedom of Information Act suffers from the law of unintended consequences. Some government people are piling everything they can find onto their websites so that they can say they've made it available to the public. You may not be able to find it but it is there somewhere.
Most data and content that we create is next to useless. Nobody will ever be interested in looking at it again. Then there is another chunk that has fractional demand. However, we need to store most of this low-level stuff somewhere just in case of some unforeseen event.
There is a saying: What do you get when you cross a fox with a chicken? A fox. When you manage low-level content and high-quality content on the same website, the low-level content smothers and eats up the high quality content. We must thus manage them separately. We need a website for the low level stuff. But our primary website should be for the high-quality content that people actually need today.
In every environment, there is a small set of content that has a disproportionate demand and value. As our content/data universe explodes, it has never been more important to manage this precious content separately from low-demand data.
Gerry McGovern
Measurement and Analysis of Large-Scale Network File System Workloads (PDF)
THE 2008 GLOBAL INTRANET STRATEGIES SURVEY: CALL FOR PARTICIPATION
Companies and organizations with intranets are invited to participate and will receive a free advance copy of the 2009 Intranet Trends Report which will be published in October 2008. (Closing date: August 31.) To participate in the 2008 Survey, send an email to
Jane McConnell
Comment on this post at our Giraffe Forum Blog
Develop a deeper understanding of your customers
You may quote freely from this issue once you give proper attribution. (A link to www.gerrymcgovern.com would be appreciated.) You are also welcome to republish this article in full once you give proper attribution and place the following link at the end of the article:
Customer Carewords
Related links
Content is Critical
Government
Intranet
Read other New Thinking articles
Next issue: Too close to your website, too far from your customers
Previous issue: News you can use
